LAIPLALAIPLA
LAIPLALAIPLA
  • About
    • About LAIPLA
    • Ambassador Outreach Program
    • Board of Directors
    • Committees
    • Administration
    • Member Firms and Companies
    • Past Presidents
    • Recent Past Presidents
    • Public Service Award
    • Diversity Fellowship
    • Bylaws
  • Events
  • Membership
  • Sponsorship
  • Contact
  • About
    • About LAIPLA
    • Ambassador Outreach Program
    • Board of Directors
    • Committees
    • Administration
    • Member Firms and Companies
    • Past Presidents
    • Recent Past Presidents
    • Public Service Award
    • Diversity Fellowship
    • Bylaws
  • Events
  • Membership
  • Sponsorship
  • Contact

TTAB Test: Is ULTIMATE GEL Merely Descriptive of Bedding Products?

December 15, 2018December 17, 2018| in The TTABlog| by John L. Welch
The USPTO refused to register the mark ULTIMATE GEL, finding it merely descriptive of “Beds for household pets; Chair cushions; Mattress toppers; Mattresses; Pillows.” Applicant Comfort Revolution pointed to five existing registrations for marks that include the word ULTIMATE for the same or related products, without disclaimer of ULTIMATE. Examining Attorney Brittany Cogan relied on nine third-party registrations either on the Supplemental Register, or registered under Section 2(f), or containing a disclaimer of ULTIMATE. How do you think this came out? In re Comfort Revolution, LLC, Serial No. 87357126 (December 12, 2018) [not precedential] (Opinion by Judge Linda A. Kuczma).

The Board found the word ULTIMATE to be laudatory and therefore merely descriptive of applicant’s goods. “Self-laudatory or puffing marks are regarded as a condensed form of describing the character or quality of the goods.” Wording like “ultimate,” “best,” “greatest,” and the like are generally considered laudatory and descriptive of an alleged superior quality of the goods.

The word GEL describes the nature of applicant’s goods. Third-party website evidence showed the use of “gel” to describe mattresses, dog beds, seat cushions,etc. Applicant’s website uses the word descriptively to describe pillows. From this evidence, the Board concluded that GEL is a commonly used term for bedding products to describe a feature that includes gel to keep the user of the device cool.

Finally, the Board found that the components of the applied-for mark retain their laudatory and descriptive meaning when combined. The composite mark offers no unique, incongruous, or nondescriptive meaning in relation to the goods.

Comfort Revolution lamely contended that ULTIMATE GEL could be used to sell a wide variety of products unrelated to bedding – like hair care products and boat sealant. It argued that a consumer must gather additional information in order to perceive the significance of the phrase, and therefore the mark is at most suggestive of its goods.

The Board pointed out, however, that the determination of descriptiveness must be made in relation to the goods at issue. Whether the applied-for mark has different meanings in other contexts is simply irrelevant.

The Board had no doubt that ULTIMATE GEL is merely descriptive of applicant’s bedding products, and so it affirmed the Section 2(e)(1) refusal.

Read comments and post your comment here.

TTABlog comment: WYHA?

Text Copyright John L. Welch 2018.

IP Blog Categories

  • Announcements
  • Events
  • LAIPLA News
  • The TTABlog
  • Uncategorized
  • Wegner's Top 10
  • Wegner's Writings

Archives

Previous

TTAB Finds SEAHORSE JAPANESE CUISINE, in Chinese Characters, Confusable With SEAHORSE for Restaurant/Bar Services

Next

Finding Confusion and Dilution Likely, TTAB Sustains AMERICAN EXPRESS Oppositions to AMERIXPRESS


Since 1934, LAIPLA has been educating and connecting members of the local intellectual property legal community

Pages

About 
Events
Membership
Sponsorship
Contact
Privacy Policy

Search
Contact

LAIPLA
1621 W 25th Street
Box 633
San Pedro, CA 90732
Phone: (323) 285-1654
Fax: ( 310) 878-0517
Email: office@laipla.net

© 2025 Los Angeles Intellectual Property Law Association. All Rights Reserved | Website design by Arclight Digital.