Examining Attorney Kim Teresa Moninghoff submitted evidence showing that numerous third parties have used #MAGICNUMBER108 as part of messages posted on social media during and after the 2016 World Series, expressing support for the Cubbies. There was no dispute that applicant – who may be the World’s leading expert in Cubs numerology – was the first to use the term.
The Board found that the USPTO’s evidence shows “wide use of the proposed mark in a non-trademark manner to consistently convey information about the Chicago Cubs’ World Series appearance and win after a 108-year drought.” There is no requirement that the evidence show the term used for goods in commerce.
This evidence is competent to suggest that upon encountering Applicant’s “mark,” prospective purchasers familiar with such widespread non-trademark use are unlikely to consider it to indicate the source of Applicant’s goods.”
The presence of the hash mark in applicant’s proposed mark reinforced the Board’s finding.
In the social media context, a hashtag “is a word or phrase preceded by a hash mark (#), used within a message to identify a keyword or topic of interest and facilitate a search for it.” Evidence in the record establishes that Applicant’s proposed mark #MAGICNUMBER108 has been used extensively as a hashtag to identify the Chicago Cubs’ World Series appearance and win.
The Board observed that a hashtag, when used as part of an online social media search term, generally serves no source-identifying function. It “merely facilitate[s] categorization and searching within online social media.” TMEP Section 1202.18. “Therefore, the addition of the term HASHTAG or the hash symbol (#) to an otherwise unregistrable term typically will not render the resulting composite term registrable.”
Applicant DePorter argued that his proposed mark has never been used in everyday speech, and instead is arbitrary and fanciful. The Board pointed out, however, that even if true, that does not necessarily mean the public perceives the term as a source indicator. Here, the evidence shows that the proposed mark is a “widely-used message to convey information about the Chicago Cubs baseball team.”
The Board concluded that “#MAGICNUMBER108 is perceived as part of an online social media trend related to the phrase ‘magic number 108,’ expressing affiliation with the Chicago Cubs baseball team and their 2016 World Series win after 108 years rather than as an identification of source for the goods identified in the application.”
And so the Board affirmed the refusal to register.
Read comments and post your comment here.
TTABlog comment: Do any people beyond the North Side of Chicago know (or care) what this term is supposed to refer to? If the term is informational to the teeny-weeny percentage of Americans who are Cub fans, is that enough to invoke the failure-to-function bar?
Text Copyright John L. Welch 2019.